Voted #1 restaurant in Indiana·4 Indianapolis locations·Seafood market & kitchen
Caplinger's Fresh Catch Pendleton Pike seafood kitchen
Home  /  Locations  /  Pendleton Pike
Seafood Kitchen

Caplinger's Fresh Catch
Pendleton Pike

★★★★ 4.4 · 570 Google reviewsRead our Yelp reviews → 9535 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46236 (317) 389-5378
Lawrence

Your neighborhood Seafood Kitchen

A neighborhood Seafood Kitchen on Pendleton Pike turning out fried catfish, gator bites and seafood dinners that regulars drive across Lawrence for.

What you'll find here

  • Fried fish & dinners, catfish, whiting, perch and shrimp, seasoned and fried to order
  • Fish & chips, po'boys & lobster rolls, the favorites that built our name
  • Specialty, gator bites, frog legs, calamari and seasonal seafood
  • The sides Indy loves, mac & cheese, collard greens, hush puppies and fried okra
LawrenceOaklandonMcCordsvilleFort Harrisonthe northeast side of Indianapolis

Visit Pendleton Pike

9535 Pendleton Pike
Indianapolis, IN 46236
Hours
Monday10:00 AM–8:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM–8:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM–8:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM–8:00 PM
Friday10:00 AM–9:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM–8:00 PM
SundayClosed
Directions on Google Maps See reviews on Google
What's good here

Fried fresh, golden and fast

Fried fish dinners

Fried fish dinners

Catfish, whiting, perch and tilapia, hand-breaded and fried to order.

Jumbo fried shrimp

Jumbo fried shrimp

Plump, breaded and golden, an Indy favorite.

Gator bites & the wild side

Gator bites & the wild side

Gulf gator bites, frog legs and calamari.

Po'boys and sandwiches

Po'boys & sandwiches

Loaded seafood po'boys and the award-winning fish sandwich.

Find us

Easy to reach in Indy

Order online

Hungry? Order straight from Pendleton Pike

Pickup and delivery from this location, straight off our live menu.

A look inside

Pendleton Pike, in photos

Straight from the counter

What guests say about Pendleton Pike

Real Google reviews, 4.4★ across 570 ratings.

★★★★★

"God damn this place is delicious !!!! Everything tasted so good. Seasoned to perfection. Collard greens were delectable with a little kick to them. Mac and cheese- fire. I crave this meal in my dreams. See you guys later today ! 10/10!!!!!"

CeciliaGoogle review
★★★★★

"This was some of the best seafood we've had!! We're on a trip from Oregon for a wedding, and we're looking for places to eat while we're here for the week. This place is a WALK AWAY from where we're staying, and it is amazing!! This location is so cute, we love the look out the trailer. We had…"

Laura BradshawGoogle review
★★★★★

"I really enjoy their food. I have been here 4 times and the Catfish is ALWAYS seasoned and fried perfectly. I have never been a tarter sauce person but their's is delicious! It is sweet, kinda like honey mustard. Definitely will return."

NthosjeansGoogle review
Good to know

Pendleton Pike, questions, answered

What does the Caplinger's Pendleton Pike Seafood Kitchen serve?
The Pendleton Pike Seafood Kitchen at 9535 Pendleton Pike is our prepared-food location, fried catfish, fish sandwiches and dinners, fish & chips, po'boys, lobster rolls, gator bites, frog legs, calamari and classic sides like mac & cheese, collard greens and fried okra.
What are the hours at Caplinger's Pendleton Pike?
Open Monday–Thursday 10am–8pm, Friday 10am–9pm, Saturday 10am–8pm, closed Sunday. Hours can change on holidays, check Google for the latest.
Does the Pendleton Pike location sell fresh fish by the pound?
This location is a Seafood Kitchen focused on prepared food. For the full retail fresh-fish counter by the pound, visit our Shadeland or Southside markets, but the kitchen here fries up the same quality seafood to order.
Where is Caplinger's Pendleton Pike?
We're at 9535 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46236 (Lawrence), serving Lawrence, Oaklandon, McCordsville, Fort Harrison and the northeast side of Indianapolis.
Four neighborhoods, one family

Other Caplinger's locations